Low Rates and Ever Higher Debt

  • Brian O’Donnell, Executive-in-Residence, Global Risk Institute
  • Richard Nesbitt, Chief Executive Officer, Global Risk Institute
Photo of a sign on a wood post which reads "Danger: cliff edge".

Introduction

At the Global Risk Institute we are often asked what is the most significant risk facing the global economy. While there are many emerging risks and opportunities that we are actively researching, including cybersecurity, geopolitics, regulatory change and climate change, we see the explosion of debt levels world-wide, fueled by extremely low interest rates, as the single biggest and most immediate risk.

We imagine Adam Smith’s invisible hand has its fingers crossed. Since the financial crisis, unprecedented levels of central bank intervention and the resultant debt level build up have left the financial world in an ever more precarious position. As we all know, free economies run through cycles of growth and recession, with leverage generally exaggerating both sides of the cycle. With the current growth cycle getting a little long in the tooth (at approaching 84 months; average expansion phase is 58 months), it is appropriate to ask ourselves what the next recession will look like, in the context of this high leverage.

While it is a mugs game to hypothesise about the precise timing of the next recession (Robert Reich famously states that he predicted the 1991 recession so well because he had been predicting it every year for five years), it is appropriate to consider its nature and magnitude. One can characterize the state of the global economy since the financial crisis as slow growing and interrupted by periodic crises:

  • Global economic growth has struggled since 2010, making this one of the most tepid recoveries;
  • Short term interest rates have been held close to zero (and for over $11 trillion of securities become negative) since the recession;
  • And, for the first time in modern memory, central banks across the developed world have engaged in quantitative easing, buying trillions of dollars of marketable debt securities and forcing longer term (usually market determined) interest rates down across the curve.